1. Hutzot Hayotzer (the Artists' Colony) — Outside Jaffa Gate
A whole lane of working studios — the best single hour of Judaica shopping in the city.
Hutzot HaYotzer, known in English as the Artists' Colony, is an arts and crafts lane just west of the Old City walls, outside Jaffa Gate. It is home to goldsmiths and silversmiths working in jewellery, fine art and Judaica, generally in a modern, minimalist register.
The reason to start here is that you are buying from the maker rather than from a shop that bought from a maker. You can watch the work being done, ask about commissions, and compare a dozen very different hands within a few minutes' walk — which is the fastest way to work out what you actually like before you spend seriously.
The lane also hosts Jerusalem's international arts and crafts fair each summer, when the whole area fills with stalls and the evenings run late.
Good to know: Go on a weekday morning when the studios are actually working — the atmosphere and the conversations are completely different from a Friday rush.